Keyboard Sustain Pedal Buying Guide: Choosing the Right One

Choosing the right sustain pedal can significantly enhance your keyboard playing experience. This buying guide will help you navigate the options and select the perfect pedal to match your needs and budget. We'll explore key features to consider, such as pedal sturdiness, the importance of a polarity switch, and the distinct advantages of piano-style pedals. Whether you're a gigging musician or a home player, understanding these factors will ensure you choose a pedal that provides reliable performance and enhances your musical expression.This guide covers essential aspects to consider when purchasing a sustain pedal, from the durability and weight of the pedal to its compatibility with your keyboard and the subtle nuances of playing experience. We'll help you determine whether a standard sustain pedal or a more expressive piano-style pedal is the best fit for your musical style and performance environment. By the end, you'll be equipped to make an informed decision and invest in a sustain pedal that elevates your playing to the next level.

Read more: 5 Best Piano Pedals for Your Digital Piano

Durability and Weight

The sturdiness of a sustain pedal is crucial for longevity and consistent performance. A heavy, metal pedal like the Add Module SP1 (shown in the video) offers superior stability on stage, preventing accidental movement during performances. This ensures reliable responsiveness and prevents frustrating interruptions. Conversely, lighter pedals, often made of plastic, might slide or shift during use, especially on less-than-ideal surfaces.

Casio SP3 sustain pedal
Casio SP3 sustain pedal

Consider the environment where you'll primarily use the pedal. A gigging musician needs a robust, heavy-duty pedal that can withstand the rigors of transport and frequent setup/teardown. Home users might find a lighter, less expensive model perfectly adequate.

Polarity Switch: A Crucial Feature

A polarity switch is a hidden gem that often gets overlooked when purchasing a sustain pedal. This small switch allows you to reverse the pedal's polarity, ensuring compatibility with your keyboard or digital piano. Some keyboards might have an opposite polarity than the default setting of the sustain pedal. This means you might find your pedal acting in reverse (pressed = no sustain, released = sustain).

Close-up of a sustain pedal with a polarity switch
Close-up of a sustain pedal with a polarity switch

Always prioritize a sustain pedal with a built-in polarity switch. This simple feature saves you the hassle of potential wiring adjustments or incompatibility issues. It's a small detail that significantly improves the user experience.

Sustain pedal lacking a polarity switch
Sustain pedal lacking a polarity switch

Piano-Style Sustain Pedals: An Alternative

For pianists or keyboard players who desire a more authentic piano playing experience, a piano-style sustain pedal offers a different feel and response. These pedals typically feature a more substantial build and a wider, more comfortable footrest. The response can feel more natural and expressive, providing better control over the sustain.

Piano-style sustain pedal
Piano-style sustain pedal

The added depth and nuance of a piano-style pedal can enhance your playing, particularly for classical or jazz music where subtle control over sustain is crucial. However, it is important to weigh the benefits against the potentially higher price point compared to standard sustain pedals.

Close up of a piano-style sustain pedal
Close up of a piano-style sustain pedal

Conclusion: Choosing the Right Pedal for Your Needs

Selecting a sustain pedal depends heavily on your individual needs and budget. For gigging musicians, a durable, metal pedal with a polarity switch is highly recommended. Home users might find a lighter, more affordable option sufficient. The piano-style pedal is a great choice for pianists and those who seek enhanced expressiveness.

Speaker presenting tips on buying a sustain pedal
Speaker presenting tips on buying a sustain pedal

Always check for a polarity switch to avoid compatibility problems. Consider the pedal's weight and build quality to ensure it suits your playing style and performance environment. The investment in a quality sustain pedal significantly impacts your playing experience and the overall sound of your music.