This review delves into the Hifiman HE-60 'Baby Orpheus' headphones, exploring both their sonic capabilities and the significant cost involved in restoring and optimizing their performance. We examine two distinct setups: a budget-conscious restoration and a high-end "audio overkill" configuration, detailing the expenses involved in each. This allows for a comprehensive understanding of the financial commitment required to experience the HE-60's unique sound signature.The HE-60's sound is characterized by exceptional clarity and speed, particularly evident in its rendering of metallic instruments. However, its performance isn't without flaws. We'll analyze its strengths and weaknesses, including its often-criticized bass response and inconsistent midrange, and assess how different amplification significantly impacts the overall listening experience. Ultimately, we'll determine whether the HE-60's unique sonic characteristics justify its hefty price tag in today's competitive headphone market.
Pros And Cons
- Very fast transient response
- Exceptional transient response for metallic instruments, providing a realistic, clear, and detailed sound
- Excellent top-end for acoustical instruments (guitars, violins, etc.)
- High dynamic range, especially in the treble and mid-range
- Mid-range response is inconsistent, depending on the vocalist and recording
- Lack of bass response; bass is present but lacks impact, feeling, and presence
- Soundstage is not impressive despite wider sound with the Woo amplifier
- Can sound sterile and lacking warmth, especially in the bass and midrange with the Jade amplifier
- Can be punishing in the upper mid-range with certain vocalists, especially with the Jade amplifier.
Read more: Top 5 Wooden Piano Benches
Cost Breakdown: Baseline vs. Overkill
This review covers the total cost of the HE-60 restoration project, comparing a baseline build with high-quality equipment and an 'audio overkill' option.
The baseline build includes the used HE-60 ($1500), replacement pads ($33), miscellaneous cleaning supplies and accessories ($25), and aftermarket grills and headband ($100). The total for the baseline build comes to approximately $1658.
The 'audio overkill' setup significantly increases the cost due to high-end equipment. This includes the Jade amp ($700), Woo Audio WES amplifier ($4500), and a high-end DAC (either $500 or $2500), resulting in a total cost of around $8658.
Sound Quality: Crystal Clear, Yet Flawed
The HE-60's sound can best be described as 'crystalline clear,' providing an abundance of detail. However, this clarity isn't perfect; some areas are lacking.
The headphone's speed is a standout feature, rivaling that of modern high-end headphones. Metallic sounds exhibit a remarkable shine and shimmer.
Conversely, the bass response is often criticized for being sterile and lacking impact, while the midrange performance varies greatly depending on the vocalist or recording.
Amplifier Impact: Jade vs. Woo WES
The Jade amp provides a very detailed sound but lacks warmth and lower midrange, resulting in a slightly punishing upper midrange in some instances.
The Woo WES amplifier significantly improves the overall sound, adding warmth and filling out the lower midrange. This makes the listening experience more pleasing.
However, the Woo WES does slightly reduce the top-end resolution, creating a smoother, less crystalline sound but a more forgiving and balanced overall presentation.
Imaging, Soundstage and Dynamics
Imaging is exceptional, particularly for metallic instruments, but the soundstage is relatively narrow. The Woo WES amplifier widens the soundstage slightly.
Dynamics are impressive, with the HE-60 transitioning effortlessly between quiet and loud passages. However, this exceptional dynamic range can be overwhelming for some listeners.
While impressive, the dynamic capabilities and soundstage limitations are not necessarily worth the price point given today's headphone market.
Final Verdict: A Niche Experience
Ultimately, the HE-60's performance doesn't justify its high cost, especially in comparison to modern headphones.
While it offers exceptional clarity and transient response in specific areas, especially with carefully mastered recordings, its limitations in bass response and midrange consistency hold it back.
The HE-60 is better suited as a passion project or a unique listening experience rather than a top-tier all-around headphone. The price-to-performance ratio simply doesn't match modern alternatives.